International – Wetmachine

Title II, Robert McDowell, And The Boy Who Cried ‘Black Helicopter.’

Harold February 23, 2015 February 24, 2015International, Series of Tubes, Tales of the Sausage Factory

I noted with some considerable interest the February 17 Wall St. Journal Op Ed by Former FCC Commissioner Robert McDowell and Gordon M. Goldstein describing how reclassifying broadband as a Title II telecommunications service will invariably lead to �the International Telecommunications Union (ITU), a regulatory arm of the United Nations� asserting jurisdiction over the Internet. As a consequence, McDowell warns us, the ITU will allow freedom-hating dictatorships such as Russia and China to take control of �Internet governance,� extend censorship to the Internet, and generally crush freedom-as-we-know-it.

What I noted, however, was the remarkable similarity between this column and McDowell�s 2010 Wall St. Journal Op Ed on the same theme. �The U.N. Black Helicopters will swoop down and carry off our Internet if we try to reign in carriers from abusing consumers and adopt real net neutrality� has become a perennial favorite for McDowell and some others. We heard the same cries in 2012 as we geared up for the ITU�s World Conference on International Telecommunications (WCIT). In the lead up to the WCIT, the refusal of then-FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski to close the inquiry into whether to reclassify broadband as Title II prompted more than a few anti-net neutrality advocates to claim that supporting Title II, or even just plain �ol net neutrality, gave aid and comfort to Russia, China, Iran, etc. in their efforts to use the ITU to take over the Internet.

So no surprise, as we move closer to actually reclassifying broadband and getting strong network neutrality rules in place, it is time once again for the annual reunion tour of Robert McDowell and the Black Helicopter Band. Despite making the same wrong prediction about the ITU for the last 5 years, we will once again see Robert McDowell and the usual suspects singing backup that reclassifying broadband will serve the nefarious agenda of Russia, China and anyone else we don’t like by allowing the U.N. to swoop in with their black helicopters and carry off our Internet and crush our freedoms.

For those new to this performance, I debunk it (once again) below . . .

President Obama Says Some Good Things About Net Neutrality and Intellectual Property.

Harold October 13, 2014 October 13, 2014Fighting the IP Mafia, International, Series of Tubes, Tales of the Sausage Factory

Everyone likes to get mad at President Obama these days. So I figured I would briefly highlight some good things Obama said during this Town Hall Meeting last week while I was off doing the Jewish holiday thing. After the holiday, I saw an email with the subject: “Obama Talks About Net Neutrality & Intellectual Property.”

I am sufficiently weird that “Obama Talks About Net Neutrality and Intellectual Property” is probably the most irresistible clickbait headline for me that I can think of, so of course I was hooked.

Speaking of clickbait, more below . . . .

Net Neutrality Videos Much More Interesting Than I Could Ever Make.

Harold June 3, 2014 June 3, 2014Censorship Public and Private, How Democracy Works, Or Doesn't, International, Series of Tubes, Tales of the Sausage Factory

It’s impossible to keep up all the videos about net neutrality. Heck, I have been delinquent in flogging my own. For example, I have two new “5 Minutes With Harold Feld” videos out: one on what I call “virtual redlining” (about how permitting prioritized content invariably leads to targeting and segmenting audiences in ways that recreate all the usual stereotypes and re-marginalizing traditionally marginalized communities) and this on “rural virtual redlining” (how allowing prioritization further isolates rural and exacerbates the digital divide).

As you can see from the pathetic hit counts if you click through, my personal contributions are a total flop. Why? Because, in my own words, 5 Minutes with Harold Feld takes “insanely complicated and incredibly boring stuff and make it slightly less boring because THIS STUFF IS IMPORTANT.” So even at my most wildly successful, I am only slightly less boring. This apparently does not help much.

However, lots of much more interesting and entertaining people have used the power of online video — and even traditional media — to provide a much less boring perspective. I’m listing my top 5 Internet videos below the break. Please feel free to add links to your favorites in the comment section, assuming you did not fall asleep trying to watch my videos.

Actually interesting Net Neutrality videos below . . .

Appreciation: Professor Robert B. Seidman RIP: 1920-2014

Harold April 7, 2014 April 7, 2014General, International, Tales of the Sausage Factory

On April 3, 2014, the world lost a true giant of the public interest. Professor Robert B. Seidman, of Boston University law school died of heart attack in his home in Milton, MA at age 94. With him was his wife of more than 65 years, co-author, co-professor, and all around partner in every sense of the word, Professor Ann Seidman. You can read a far too abbreviated obituary here, see his CV here, and a list of publications here. �None of these, of course, come even vaguely close to capturing Bob’s importance in the world generally, or in my life personally.

I’ll insert this video here where Bob and Ann explain their work. I try to put some of what Bob did and what he taught me below �. . .

http://youtu.be/iTc5f8Qv-o8

Will Walden Wipe Out DMCA and CISPA To Take Out Net Neutrality In The Name of “Internet Freedom?”

Harold April 10, 2013 April 10, 2013How Democracy Works, Or Doesn't, International, Series of Tubes, Tales of the Sausage Factory

Today, the House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Communications and Technology will begin mark up of the so-called �Internet Freedom Bill.� As explained in the Majority Briefing Memo, we�re still on about that whole �the ITU will take control of the Internet and black helicopters will come for out name servers� thing.�� Unfortunately, as keeps happening with this, it looks like some folks want to hijack what should be a show of unity to promote their own partisan domestic agenda. Specifically, does the bill as worded undercut the (by accident or design) the Federal Communications Commission�s (FCC) authority to do things like Network Neutrality?

As I elaborate below, however, this is not so much a stab at net neutrality and the FCC generally as it is a murder/suicide. You can’t claim that this clips the wings of the FCC to do net neutrality by making a law that the U.S. is opposed to “government control” of the Internet without also eliminating laws that deal with cybersecurity, copyright enforcement online, privacy, and a range of other stuff that are just as much “government control” of the Internet — but that most Republicans opposed to net neutrality actually like. Plus, as I noted last week when discussing the rural call completion problem, taking the FCC out of the equation may have some unforseen nasty consequences that even Republicans might not like.

More below . . . .

I’m Testifying Tomorrow And It Will Be WCIT-Awesome!

Harold February 4, 2013 February 4, 2013Censorship Public and Private, I Fear These Things, International, Tales of the Sausage Factory

I will be testifying tomorrow at a joint hearing by the House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Telecom and Technology and Several of the Foreign Affairs Committees tomorrow,�February 5 at 10:30 a.m. The hearing, Fighting For Internet Freedom: Dubai and Beyond�will focus on the World Conference on�International�Telecommunications (WCIT) that took place in Dubai this past December.

If you click on the Hearing Homepage�tomorrow, there should be a link for livestreaming. I am hoping this will prove entertaining and informative. Well, at least informative.

Stay tuned . . .